For lunch today we had cookies for dessert and of course I had to try several of them to see if I could taste something new or be inspired. I had a peanut butter cookie that was pretty good and an interesting thumbprint cookie with what seemed to be apricot jam in the middle. Taking those two ideas together I decided to try peanut butter and jelly thumbprint cookies. For some reason A. is not a huge fan of PB&J sandwiches but maybe I’ll get her to like these cookies. The cookies looked really good and had great flavor but I think I need to leave them in the oven just a tad longer since they seemed a little too soft and chewy…
Advertisement
I love thumbprints although I don’t really like peanut butter. Even though they were softer than you desired, they still tasted quite good b/c of the grainy texture (reminiscent of the inside of a Reese’s cup). Thanks!
Very good, but fall apart easily. They need to be a little more sturdy.
I liked the flavors but a little too sweet… could feel the sugar on my tongue