Growing up I ate a lot of peanut butter sandwiches with sliced bananas on top. The two flavors were great together. So one night as I was in my kitchen staring at 3 bananas that were starting to become over ripened, I thought about making banana bread and what I could do to jazz it up a bit… the result — banana peanut butter bread.

The recipe I’ve used for banana bread over the years is fool proof. I got the recipe from Mrs. Jim, a dear family friend who was the first person that introduced me to the world of baking. I spent lots of time in Mrs. Jim’s kitchen licking the spoon and helping her make all kinds of breads, cakes and cookies. With this recipe in hand and my daughter A. ready to help, I figured I couldn’t go wrong just by adding a little peanut butter to it. So I added half a cup of peanut butter to the blended bananas and hoped for the best. The batter was yummy and A. agreed by licking the spoon with me.
At 45 minutes, I got a little worried that my little experiment wouldn’t work since the toothpick I inserted came out all gooey. The oven was on 350 degrees so I wasn’t sure what was going on. Normally by this time the banana bread would be ready to go. I ended up leaving the bread in for another 15 minutes and it seemed to do the trick.
Upon tasting the bread it seemed to be OK, except it wasn’t as moist as my banana bread normally is and the peanut butter overpowered the banana a bit. My husband C. tasted it and he seemed to be fine with it, not really noticing too much of the peanut butter. I decided to take it into the office for some more objective criticism. The reviews were mixed. Some people thought there was too much peanut butter and others thought there could be more. I did get a couple of comments about it being a little dry.
On a scale from 1-10, the high was an 8 and the low was a 4, with the average at about 6. So for my first test, I came in above average. Not too bad for just winging it with the peanut butter…